Pat,
I suggest you should start a new topic on this, as Jane will also get notified on all the replies...
1.) We never received your URL which you said you have sent before.
2.) I checked and login as member1 at your website, I suspect that you CHANGED the template at View Options. and NOT using the default token: [REGISTER]. rather you hard coded a hyper link in the template.
This way, the hyper link will always show.
If you want to change the display link, you can do this way: (use IfEmpty statement, please refer to Token guide, you can find the link at your View Options page.)
[REGISTERLINK|<a href="{0}">SIGN ME UP</a>]
Please correct me if I am wrong.
3.) if possible, please provide admin access.
So far, I don't think it is a module problem. (You can restore to default template and try again.)